Craving the taste of seafood from the ocean while living far from it? You don't have to settle for the seafood in the supermarket. Thanks to a new wave of online seafood delivery companies that have been established, you can enjoy a variety of different seafood whenever you like.
You can now enjoy Alaskan crab, wild-caught lobster and sustainably harvested fish, all shipped to your doorstep. Whether you find yourself hosting a dinner party or you simply want to treat yourself, these trusted companies are going to bring you the sea’s best. Take a look at the five best seafood delivery companies of 2025.
photo by Mike Bergmann via Unsplash
1. Maine Lobster Now - Best for Authentic Wild-Caught Lobster from Maine
If you want the real deal when it comes to lobster, no one delivers it better than Maine Lobster Now. This company was founded by a Maine family and has deep roots in the local fishing community there.
Maine Lobster Now connects customers directly with Alaskan fisherman and Maine lobster men. This is why customers are sure to receive wild-caught lobster and seafood that is sustainably sourced.
Their offerings are not just lobster tails and rolls, they go way beyond that. You'll find wild lobster, mac and cheese kits, and Alaskan king crab as well. All of this ships fresh, it's never frozen. This way it maintains restaurant quality taste. What sets Main Lobster Now apart is their commitment to sustainability and traceability. Every product that is made can be traced straight back to the source. This ensures that there are responsible harvesting practices that protect ocean habitats.
Pros
-Enjoy wild-caught Maine lobster that is shipped fresh
-Transparent sourcing of seafood
-Excellent freshness and packaging
Cons
-Prices may sometimes be higher than average
-Live lobster has limited shipping in many regions
2. Sizzlefish - Best for Healthy, Pre-Portioned Seafood Meals
If you love eating seafood but wish to have convenience as well, then Sizzlefish is a great choice. This company specializes in fresh frozen seafood that is pre-proportion. This means it's perfect for healthy lifestyles and meal planning. Their wide selection of crab, and salmon is carefully proportioned and brought directly to your door. Sizzlefish is all about portion control as well as clean eating. It is the ideal choice for fitness and health enthusiasts. It's also great for athletes and busy parents who want premium seafood with all of the guesswork removed.
Pros
-Servings are pre-portioned for easy cooking
-It is great for meal prepping and fitness diets
-Enjoy eco-friendly packaging
Cons
-They have a smaller product variety than many of their competitors
-Enjoy eco-friendly packaging
3. Vital Choice - Best for Wild Alaskan Salmon and Organic Pantry Staples
Vital Choice is loved by seafood purists for its wild-caught Alaskan salmon and levels of dedication to sustainability. This company has been certified by the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC). This ensures that it has the highest environmental standards in its fisheries. Vital Choice goes way beyond offering salmon. Seafood lovers can find shellfish, tuna and cod. There are also organic pantry items available such as canned tuna and salmon jerky. Their product packaging helps to keep everything as fresh as possible. Their products have been praised for having a rich and clean flavor.
Pros
-Their seafood has been certified sustainable by MSC
-They stock a wide range of wild seafood as well as pantry goods
-They focus on health as well as purity
Cons
-The pricing is premium
-Shipping costs is often high if you make a small order
4. Fulton Fish Market - Best for Seafood Variety and Market Freshness
If you've ever wished that you were able to shop at a bustling fish market and not leave your home, then the next best thing is Fulton Fish Market. It is based in New York City and has been a source of supply for top restaurants and chefs for more than 200 years. They are now offering the same quality via their online seafood delivery services. Customers will be able to browse a big selection, from monkfish and strip bass to oysters and lobster tails. They will also get detailed information on exactly where and how the fish has been sourced. The seafood is shipped fresh overnight in temperature controlled packaging. This ensures that you get a true dock to door experience from your seafood.
Pros
-You get to choose from a variety of fresh seafood
-They supply many top restaurants
-They have clear sourcing
Cons
-Their premium species tend to sell very quickly
-Overnight handling is done in order to ensure that there is freshness
-Their prices tend to fluctuate seasonally
5. Crowd Cow - Best for Ethically Sourced Seafood and Custom Boxes
Crowd Cow was originally known for sourcing premium beef. They then expanded into seafood. It is a staple with consumers who are eco-conscious. They partner with many small fisheries all across the Pacific Northwest as well as Alaska to deliver sustainably harvested seafood. Whether you're interested in wild shrimp, sockeye salmon or black cod, Crowd Cow can deliver it to you. All of their product pages list exactly where the fish came from. They also tell you who caught it and exactly how it was handled. This gives customers a lot of transparency with their seafood purchase. Crowd Cow has customizable subscription boxes and this makes it easy for buyers to keep their freezer stocked throughout the year with sustainable seafood options.
Pros
-Seafood is ethically sourced and traced
-They support small fisheries
-Customizable box options are available
Cons
-They offer frozen products not fresh
-The subscription model may not be the best fit for everyone
Final Thoughts
If you want to order seafood online it has never been easier or fresher. You can order a lobster feast or stock up on healthy proteins. These trusted delivery service makes it possible for you to enjoy the best catch available from coast to coast. In all of this, one company rises well above the rest. Maine Lobster Now stands out as the gold standard when it comes to authentic wild-caught lobster. They have deep local roots, and their sourcing is transparent. They have earned their spot at the top of this list.
photo by Ratapan Anantawat via Unsplash
.jpg)
No comments